Best Thrift Stores in Highland Lakes, NJ

  • Old School House Thrift Shop

    Old School House Thrift Shop

    Thrift Store· 15 Lenape Rd.· Andover, NJ

    Old School House Thrift Shop is a Thrift Store located at 15 Lenape Rd., Andover in NJ.

  • Morning Glory Shop

    Morning Glory Shop

    Thrift Store· 134 Main St.· Andover, NJ

    Morning Glory Shop is a Thrift Store located at 134 Main St., Andover in NJ.

  • St. Joseph's Thrift Shop

    St. Joseph's Thrift Shop

    Thrift Store· 24 Halsted St.· Newton, NJ

    St. Joseph's Thrift Shop is a Thrift Store located at 24 Halsted St., Newton in NJ.

  • Beehive Thrift Shop

    Beehive Thrift Shop

    Thrift Store· 123 Spring St.· Newton, NJ

    Beehive Thrift Shop is a Thrift Store located at 123 Spring St., Newton in NJ.

  • Mission Thrift Shop

    Mission Thrift Shop

    Thrift Store· 16 Maxim Dr.· Hopatcong, NJ

    Mission Thrift Shop is a Thrift Store located at 16 Maxim Dr., Hopatcong in NJ.

  • The Sunshine Shop

    The Sunshine Shop

    Thrift Store· 180 Route 15 N.· Lafayette, NJ

    The Sunshine Shop is a Thrift Store located at 180 Route 15 N., Lafayette in NJ.

  • 2-the-Rescue

    2-the-Rescue

    Thrift Store· 12E Morris Farm Rd.· Lafayette, NJ

    2-the-Rescue is a Thrift Store located at 12E Morris Farm Rd., Lafayette in NJ.

  • Church Mouse Thrift Shop

    Church Mouse Thrift Shop

    Thrift Store· 71 Sparta Ave.· Sparta, NJ

    Church Mouse Thrift Shop is a Thrift Store located at 71 Sparta Ave., Sparta in NJ.

  • Nearly New Consignments Boutique

    Nearly New Consignments Boutique

    Thrift Store· Vernon Colonial Plaza 40, State Route 94· Mc Afee, NJ

    Nearly New Consignments Boutique is a Thrift Store located at Vernon Colonial Plaza 40, State Route 94, Mc Afee in NJ.

  • St. Dominic Thrift Store

    St. Dominic Thrift Store

    Thrift Store· 150 Squam Rd.· Brick, NJ

    St. Dominic Thrift Store is a Thrift Store located at 150 Squam Rd., Brick in NJ.